Recent arrivals (top to bottom):
- The Puzzler's War by Eyal Kless - from HarperVoyager for review (unsolicited)
- The Love Story of Missy Carmichael by Beth Morrey - from Putnam for review
- American Dirt by Jeanine Cummins - purchased; pre-ordered in 2019
- The Antidote for Everything by Kimmery Martin - from Berkley for review
- Such a Fun Age by Kiley Reid - purchased
I mentioned the fact that I pre-ordered American Dirt because of the controversy. It's an uncomfortable irony that the book arrived literally on the day that numerous posts were made about the book's problems and a recommended-instead reading pile image passed around. Will I still read it? I plan to, yes. I already paid for it, after all, but when I get to it I'll watch for the harmful stereotypes described in various articles about the book. And, if I have the time, I'll read the two books that I have from that recommended list, first. I'm not in any hurry to read American Dirt, now. When I bought the book, it sounded like exactly what I was looking for but I would have avoided it if I'd seen what the author had to say.
Books finished since last Malarkey:
- If Cats Disappeared from the World by Genki Kawamura
And, I had one DNF, this week: A Good Neighborhood by Therese Anne Fowler. I got to page 137 (a little more than halfway, I think). I've heard a ton of positive buzz about this book and I know people who have already enjoyed it, so I recommend getting other opinions if you're thinking about reading it. It has a 4.05 rating at Goodreads, so you can see that my opinion differs from the average.
Had I finished A Good Neighborhood, I was leaning toward about a 3. It's not a bad book, in my opinion, and there's a strength to the author's writing. But, I thought the characters felt a bit one-dimensional and unreal. And, I didn't like the point of view. The story is narrated by a generic set of neighbors. "We thought she was kind but a little eccentric," is an example of the writing style. The author will start a chapter that way and then smoothly alter the way the sentences are written, so that it doesn't feel like you're listening to the neighbors, anymore. Then, the next chapter or a section within a chapter will revert to the generic "we", again. At any rate, I didn't like the type of narration at all. But, it was mostly feeling like the characters were too carefully crafted, to the point of almost being caricatures, and the fact that I just wasn't enjoying the read that made me finally decide to abandon it.
- The World of Sanditon by Sara Sheridan
- Dragonshadow (Heartstone #2) by Elle Katharine White
I read a little of The World of Sanditon, this week, but not a great deal. I figure it doesn't hurt to stretch this one out and enjoy it while I'm watching the series. It's loaded with beautiful photographs and info about the time period. There are fewer photos from the actual series than from Regency England but they're gorgeous. My only problem with the book, so far, is that the photos are not labeled. I really dislike unlabeled photographs. Tell me what I'm looking at! Even if it's obvious that I'm seeing a cricket scene, I want to know the names of the actors and their roles (left to right, if you please). Otherwise, I am absolutely loving it.
Is anyone else watching Sanditon? I'm curious what others think. I've only seen one comment (and it was by someone I didn't know, on Facebook, so I chose not to respond). The other viewer thought it was a bit "too modern". I've noticed the modern music, of course, but I actually like the shift to males who are enterprising, rather than just gentlemen with huge estates.
I just began reading Dragonshadow yesterday. I abandoned A Good Neighborhood on Saturday night and didn't start anything else that evening, but I knew Dragonshadow would be next. And, I am loving it. I've only read about 40 pages but it's everything I hoped for in a sequel, so far.
Posts since last Malarkey:
- Heartstone (Heartstone #1) by Elle Katharine White (book review)
- Fiona Friday - Hello, Izzy (cat photo)
Not a big reading week, again. I think I may have to face the fact that this is not going to be a great reading year, at least for a few months. We shall see. I'll keep trying my best. I haven't heard from any of the publicists who contacted me about children's books, in the past, and I desperately miss reading and reviewing children's books, but I'm not planning to reach out to them, at this point. Maybe I'll pull some of the old favorites I kept for when grandchildren visit out and reread them, just for fun.
In other news:
I did a lot of restless channel-flipping, this week, and the only thing I managed to actually watch was The Royal. Unfortunately, I was in a terribly blue mood on the day I watched two episodes of the program. Two of the characters were cruelly killed off together and they were characters I really liked. Actually, they did great casting on that show so I pretty much like all of the main cast members, although they often brought in one who was awful and then softened. That's when they killed them off or shipped them away, after they'd been suitably tortured. Anyway, wrong day to watch two people get trapped and blown up. So, I haven't talked myself into returning to that.
I decided to move on to comfort programming — movies I've already seen and know I love, or mini series. I started watching Brideshead Revisited (the 80s version with Jeremy Irons and Anthony Andrews, who I heard left acting after marrying an heiress). I'm not sure if I'll continue. I was enjoying it, and it's fun reminiscing because I've been to Oxford, England and seen some of the sites where they filmed. But, the episodes are looooong and I'm fidgety. I also started watching but didn't finish The Great Escape, one of my all-time favorite movies. I will definitely finish that but older movies were longer so I stopped watching that for the exact same reason. I was getting fidgety and wanted to get up. I haven't seen The Great Escape in so many years that I've read the book in between viewings and know that it's quite different. The movie definitely took an interesting story that is fairly dull and technical and made it entertaining.
Hit me up with any and all recommendations for funny TV or movies. I need to keep it upbeat, right now.
©2020 Nancy Horner. All rights reserved. If you are reading this post at a site other than Bookfoolery or its RSS feed, you are reading a stolen feed. Email firstname.lastname@example.org for written permission to reproduce text or photos.
The whole American Dirt controversy has taken me by surprise. Readers have loved it, but I also sympathize with those upset by it. I didn't preorder and I'm so far down the library hold list that I won't be reading it any time soon. We'll see what happens...ReplyDelete
I'm watching Sanditon and, though it's been years since I read the book, think Jane would be appalled by the modern liberties. Still enjoying it, but frequently find myself shaking my head ;-)
It surprised me, too! The positive buzz for American Dirt started months ago and everyone seemed to love it until suddenly one day it became this big, controversial thing. I can definitely understand the problems and if/when I read it I think that it's good to go in aware of what she got wrong.Delete
Yes, "too modern" is what I'm hearing about Sanditon. I'm not bothered by the modern themes and characters. The book you read would have been finished by someone else. The newer Sanditon was started by Jane but finished by an author who wrote the remainder based on the series, rather than the other way around. So, I'd imagine the series is quite different from the older finished version, which I think just said it was by Jane Austen and "a lady".
I feel put off by American Dirt as well. Just had my first DNF for the year, Medieval Tastes. Academic writing in translation. Yikes.ReplyDelete
I just posted an article about American Dirt on Facebook and I am so totally put off, now, that I'm not even sure I'll get to it at all. I hate it that she got a 7-figure advance when the book has so many problems. Ah, sorry about the DNF but I'm glad I'm not the only one! The book I DNF'd was OK. I just decided that if I wasn't enjoying it I should give up. And, I wasn't. It wasn't the right book for me. I'm glad that other people love it, though.Delete
I'll be curious to hear what you think of American Dirt. Haven't read it myself, but have been following the controversy a bit on another blog- whose writer is still on the waiting list at his library to get ahold of a copy.ReplyDelete
It'll be a while, Jeane. After all the buzz followed by all the controversy, I'm not in a hurry to read it. I'll wait till it calls me. :)Delete
American Dirt never called to me anyway, but it's been "interesting" to say the least about the controversy. That said, I don't think death threats are the way to respond. I don't know if she's a horrible person, but it does sound like she's made some horrible decisions, not only in terms of the book, but in terms of its publicity too.ReplyDelete
I'm reading it right now. I agree with you about the death threats. OK, so she got paid waaaay too much (not worth seven figures, IMHO) and she's said some stupid things and it's got problems. But, all of those are true of a lot of popular fiction. Death threats have just become a common reaction by the angry trolls and they need to stop.Delete